Shopping for a mattress should be simple. But for many people, it feels overwhelming. Dozens of brands, confusing materials, firmness ratings that feel subjective, and online quizzes that promise answers but rarely deliver confidence.
That’s why Big Sandy Superstore uses a proven in-store system called Find Your Fit. Instead of guessing or relying on marketing claims, this process helps customers feel real differences, narrow choices logically, and choose a mattress that truly fits their body and sleep needs.
If you’ve ever wondered how to find the right mattress, this guide breaks the process down step by step.
Why Most Mattress Shopping Goes Wrong
Most mattress buyers make decisions based on:
- Brand recognition
- Online reviews from strangers
- Cheapest options
- A quick test in a store
The problem? Comfort is personal.
What feels amazing to one sleeper may cause pain for another.
The Find Your Fit process removes the guesswork by focusing on how your body responds, not what’s trending online.
What Is the “Find Your Fit” Mattress Process?
Find Your Fit is a three-step system designed to help shoppers confidently choose the right mattress:
- Choose a mattress technology
- Dial in the right feel (firmer or softer)
- Select the right level of investment
Each step builds on the previous one, ensuring decisions are made in the correct order.
Step 1: Start With Mattress Technology (Not Brand)
The first and most important step is identifying which mattress technology feels best to your body.
Instead of trying random beds, customers test three mattresses, all with:
- A medium feel
- Similar height
- Different construction types
This keeps variables controlled so you can focus on one thing: how each technology supports and relieves pressure for you.
The Three Mattress Technologies
Memory foam is designed to contour closely to your body, distributing weight evenly and reducing pressure points.
What it feels like
- Deep, cradling support
- Minimal motion transfer
- Slower response
Best for
- Side sleepers
- Couples
- People with shoulder, hip, or joint pain
- Sleepers who prefer a hugging sensation
Memory foam often feels dramatically different from coil-based mattresses, which is why testing it first is critical.
Hybrid mattresses combine foam comfort layers with a coil support system underneath.
What it feels like
- Balanced support and cushioning
- More responsiveness than memory foam
- Better airflow than all-foam beds
Best for
- Combination sleepers
- Heavier individuals
- Couples who want support without too much sink
- Shoppers unsure between foam and coils
Many sleepers land here because hybrids offer the best of both worlds.
Innerspring mattresses use a coil-based support system with lighter comfort layers on top.
What it feels like
- More traditional, buoyant support
- Strong edge stability
- Faster response when you move
Best for
- Back sleepers
- Stomach sleepers
- Hot sleepers
- Anyone who dislikes the “sink-in” feeling of foam
Trying innerspring alongside foam and hybrid helps immediately clarify preferences.
Why This Step Matters So Much
Choosing the right technology first:
- Eliminates entire categories that won’t work for you
- Prevents overthinking firmness too early
- Creates confidence instead of confusion
Once technology is chosen, everything else becomes easier.
Step 2: Fine-Tune the Feel (Firmer or Softer)
After selecting a preferred mattress technology, the next step is dialing in feel.
This always starts from medium to give you a point of reference.
Why?
Medium firmness acts as a neutral baseline. From there:
- Softer increases pressure relief and contouring
- Firmer increases stability and surface support
Going Softer
A softer feel may help if you:
- Sleep on your side
- Feel pressure in shoulders or hips
- Prefer a plush, cushioned surface
Going Firmer
A firmer feel may help if you:
- Sleep on your back or stomach
- Feel lower back strain
- Want less sink and more surface support
This step prevents one of the most common mattress mistakes: choosing a bed that feels good for five minutes but causes discomfort overnight.
Step 3: Choose the Right Level of Investment
Once technology and feel are determined, the final step is selecting the right investment level.
This reframes the price in a smarter way. Basing the decision on how long you want the mattress to perform, not just upfront cost.
Short-Term Investment
Best for:
- Guest rooms
- Kids’ rooms
- Temporary living situations
- Budget-focused needs
These mattresses deliver comfort but use materials designed for lighter or shorter-term use.
Long-Term Investment
Best for:
- Primary bedrooms
- Couples sleeping nightly
- Heavier sleepers
- Shoppers prioritizing durability and consistency
Higher-quality materials, stronger support systems, and longer comfort life define this category.
This step ensures you’re not over-buying or under-buying for your needs.
Why the Find Your Fit Process Works Better Than Online Mattress Quizzes
Online mattress quizzes ask questions like:
- How do you sleep?
- Do you sleep hot?
- What firmness do you like?
But they can’t:
- Measure pressure relief
- Show real firmness differences
- Account for body weight distribution
- Let couples test motion transfer together
Find Your Fit uses real-world testing, not assumptions.
Your body gives the answers instantly.
Who Benefits Most From Find Your Fit?
This process is especially effective for:
- First-time mattress buyers
- Couples with different sleep preferences
- Shoppers overwhelmed by too many options
- People who have returned mattresses before
- Anyone who wants confidence in their purchase
It replaces trial-and-error with clarity.
Common Questions About Finding the Right Mattress
How long should I test each mattress?
Spend at least 5–10 minutes in your normal sleep position on each option. Short tests lead to poor decisions.
Is medium firmness really best to start with?
Yes. Medium provides a neutral reference point, making differences between technologies and feels more obvious.
Can couples with different needs use this process?
Absolutely. It helps identify a shared technology first, then fine-tunes feel and support to meet both needs.
The Biggest Advantage: Confidence
Customers who use the Find Your Fit process:
- Decide faster
- Second-guess less
- Experience higher satisfaction
- Are happier long-term
That confidence comes from feeling the difference, not just reading about it.
Final Thoughts: Finding the Right Mattress Doesn’t Have to Be Complicated
You don’t need to memorize mattress specs, find the latest mattress rankings, take advice on what’s best from someone who isn’t you, or decode marketing buzzwords.
You just need a process that:
- Identifies the right technology
- Dials in comfort level
- Matches investment level to what you’re comfortable with.
That’s exactly what Find Your Fit delivers.
Ready to Find Your Fit?
Visit your local Big Sandy Superstore and experience the Find Your Fit mattress process in person with guidance from our trained sleep specialists.
Find a Store Near Me
Ready to Find Your Fit? Stop by a Big Sandy Superstore to explore mattresses in person.
See Locations